Hot Topics

The "analysts who disagree whether" Boyd and Parker were disfigured before or after death know little of Iroquois methods. Answer: Before, as much as possible. In truth, they were fortunate that Sullivan was so near, else they would have been burned alive.
For details see Eckert, The Jesuit Relations, or La Salle's Diary.

I think that whether disfigurement was done before or after is really beside the point. It is really an argument about Savagery. My question to you is wether you're suggesting that Boyd and Parker were innocents on a lark? What were they doing there? In other words, is intended arson - the whole point of their scouting mission - a civilized act? That is which violence is worse?

Boyd & Parker were victims of outrage and frustration, some people fail to understand the history and meaning behind the Sullivan Clinton Campaign. The Seneca had allied themselves with the British who favored them with gifts of trade goods, protection under the crown and false promises - "bottom line" they used them.
The American colonists had had enough of the atrocities committed by the relentless raids of the Loylists rangers and their Indian allies, and put pressure on Washington to end it - thus the Sullivan Clinton Campaign.
Boyd & Parker were no stranger to killing and scalping and I'm sure they or their buddies who were on that scouting foray wouldn't have thought twice about taking Seneca scalps wether they be men woman or children.
War brings out the worst in human beings no matter what color or creed, and that is what happened to Boyd & Parker, if someone came into your village and began to kill and burn your home, most likly you would take revenge on those responsible.

Does Scout Branch know that in 1778, the year before Sullivan/Clinton, the rebels took immediate revenge for Wyoming by the burnings of Seneca and Mingo towns by Hartley Expedition and of Indian settlements at Unadilla and Onoquaga, which, in turn, led to the Cherry Valley massacre? S/C was an opportunity for total Indian removal which NY's politicians and speculators dreamed of. The cycle of frontier violence opened the door to finance S/C even before Wyoming and Cherry Valley. Like you say, war can bring out the worst in everyone.

Scout Branch is right to say that Boyd/Parker were no trangers to killing and scalping: In their crew was the (in)famous hero, Timothy Murphy, who scalped a lone Seneca man the day before B/P were captured, then found brutalized. It was Murphy's 33rd scalping. See this footnote in Allan Eckert's Wilderness War.